Home » Medical Neglect: Legal Duties and Ethical Failures in Child Care

Medical Neglect: Legal Duties and Ethical Failures in Child Care

By

–

Medical Neglect: Legal Duties and Ethical Failures in Child Care

Destiny Schliefert and Debbie Sue Potter were arrested on November 18 and charged with second-degree murder, abuse or neglect of a child resulting in death, and four counts of first-degree child endangerment after a 3-year-old boy died of survivable neuroblastoma in Missouri. Authorities allege the mother skipped two years of recommended treatment for the child, who weighed just over 23 pounds when he was last seen by medical professionals in April 2025.

The Legal Framework of Medical Neglect

In the context of caregiving, neglect is a form of abuse where a responsible party fails to provide necessary care—including medical treatment—to someone unable to care for themselves, according to the legal definition outlined in S2. This failure can stem from carelessness, indifference, or unwillingness. In the United States, the calculus for criminal liability is severe: caregivers can face charges ranging from child endangerment to second-degree murder when that failure results in death, as demonstrated by the Missouri case detailed in S1.

The consequences extend beyond immediate legal jeopardy. Medical neglect can lead to long-term physical injuries, developmental trauma, and death. S2 notes that children experiencing neglect often suffer from malnutrition causing abnormal development patterns, stunted growth, and inadequate bone and muscle growth. Brain functioning and information processing may also be affected, leading to difficulty understanding directions, poor social comprehension, and an inability to complete academic tasks without assistance.

Distinguishing Poverty from Neglect

One of the strategic challenges in child welfare policy is disentangling genuine safety concerns from the consequences of poverty. Policymakers at federal and state levels have introduced legislation stipulating that poverty is not neglect and that children should not be removed from families based on financial hardship alone, according to S4. Yet translating this principle into practice remains complicated.

There is no single federal or state definition of what constitutes neglect, and no universal best practices or tools to guide decision-makers in identifying when economic hardship crosses the threshold into a child safety concern, S4 reports. Poverty often compounds other risk factors—mental illness, substance use, domestic violence—making it difficult to isolate financial hardship from conditions that genuinely threaten child safety. The Bipartisan Policy Center’s case study found that while frontline workers expressed confidence in their ability to make these distinctions, challenges persist in reporting and screening practices and in access to services that can help families address financial hardship outside the child welfare system.

Neglect Across the Lifespan and in Custody

The obligation to provide medical care is not limited to children. Elder abuse definitions explicitly include “passive neglect”—a caregiver’s failure to provide life’s necessities, including medical care—and “willful deprivation,” which denies necessary treatment and exposes the older adult to risk of harm, according to S5. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention defines elder abuse as an intentional act or failure to act that causes or creates a risk of harm to an adult aged 60 or older.

In custodial settings, the stakes are equally clear. Inmate Charles Jeffries died in a North Carolina detention center after vomiting blood—a sign of upper gastrointestinal bleeding—yet the nurse on duty administered Zofran rather than transport him to a hospital, according to S3. Over 24 hours passed before deputies took him to the emergency room; he arrived pulseless. Patients generally survive such ordeals if they seek care immediately. Jeffries’ death is part of what S3 describes as a larger trend of chronic medical neglect in Western North Carolina detention facilities, where facility compliance with administrative standards does not guarantee adequacy of care.

International Dimensions

The broader stakes of medical neglect appear in detention contexts globally. Amjad al-Najjar, director-general and spokesman of the Palestinian Prisoners’ Club, reported that approximately 9,500 Palestinian detainees in Israeli prisons face starvation, medical neglect, and physical and psychological torture, according to S6. Denial of adequate food, medical treatment, clothing, and hygiene supplies has led to a deterioration in detainees’ health and the spread of diseases, including scabies affecting an estimated 80 percent of detainees. Recently released prisoners have shown symptoms while detainees continue to be denied necessary medicines and treatment.

What This Signals

The Missouri case illustrates the most extreme end of the spectrum: a survivable cancer, a two-year gap in treatment, and a child who weighed 23 pounds at death. But the legal and ethical framework extends from that tragedy through the ambiguities of poverty-based neglect investigations, into nursing homes and jail cells, and across international detention systems. The common thread is a caregiver’s legal duty to act—and the consequences when they do not.

Sources

Photo: Tasha Kostyuk / Unsplash (Unsplash License)

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

Crime & Fraud

People in the News

News

World News