PHOENIX, November 20, 2026 — Annie Anderson, 53, pleaded guilty to negligent homicide Friday in the 2005 “Baby Skylar” case, closing a two-decade investigation that began with a newborn found dead in a Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport bathroom. The plea deal, which dismisses first-degree murder charges and carries a sentence of one to 3.75 years or probation, was made possible by forensic genetic genealogy, a technique that has rewritten the calculus for cold case investigations nationwide.
The Technique
Forensic genetic genealogy bypasses the limits of traditional law enforcement databases. When crime scene DNA fails to match a profile in the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), investigators upload the genetic profile to public genealogy databases. There, the DNA is compared against millions of voluntary participants to identify distant relatives—third or fourth cousins—of the unknown suspect. Genealogists then build family trees backward and forward in time to narrow the suspect pool to a specific individual, allowing detectives to obtain a direct DNA sample for confirmation.
The method does not rely on the suspect having a prior criminal record or a close relative in a government database. It exploits the simple reality that millions of Americans have uploaded their genetic data to consumer sites, creating a de facto surveillance net that extends far beyond the FBI’s Next Generation Identification system.
Case Studies: From Airport Bathrooms to Severed Heads
In the Baby Skylar case, Phoenix police tracked Anderson to Washington state in 2022 using this technique. When confronted, Anderson identified herself as the mother and claimed the infant was stillborn, a version contradicted by medical examiner findings. She had been visiting Phoenix for a real estate boot camp at the time of the birth.
In Placer County, California, a severed head found near Foresthill in September 2022 went unidentified for nearly two years. Artist renderings and CODIS searches failed. In 2024, detectives sent the DNA for forensic genetic genealogy testing. Working with the FBI, investigators traced distant relatives and obtained comparison DNA to identify the victim as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., a 73-year-old Citrus Heights man never reported missing. The breakthrough led to the arrest of his wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, as an accessory, and his daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, on a murder charge.
In Fresno, a 2004 murder went cold until February 2025, when cold case investigators received a DNA hit linking Robert Castillo to the killing of Barbara Lee. The original investigation had recovered a pager at the scene tied to a disconnected number associated with Castillo, but detectives could not develop a suspect. The DNA match revived the prosecution; a preliminary hearing was underway as of November 2026.
In Greenbrier County, West Virginia, skeletal remains discovered in 2001 were identified in August 2026 as Elizabeth Jean Acton, a Virginia woman missing since 1994. CODIS and the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System had yielded no matches for over two decades. State police submitted the case to Marshall University for advanced DNA testing in September 2024; the West Virginia Office of the Chief Medical Examiner confirmed the identification ten months later.
Legal Hurdles and Department Policies
The technique operates in a legal gray zone. Privacy advocates argue that uploading crime scene DNA to public databases constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment, particularly when the suspect never consented to genetic testing. Courts have yet to establish a uniform standard. Some departments require a warrant; others treat the public databases as abandoned property open to police viewing. The FBI’s collaboration on the Foresthill case signals federal acceptance, but policies vary wildly across jurisdictions.
By the Numbers: The Backlog and the Breakthroughs
Cold cases are typically violent major felonies—murder, rape, kidnapping—not subject to statutes of limitations. Advances in DNA testing and forensics technology are solving many older cases, but a substantial backlog remains. The Orlando Police Department spent 13 years pursuing leads in the 2013 kidnapping and murder of Jim Johnson Jr. before a state cold case initiative brought agencies together to arrest four men in November 2026. Investigators used new DNA technology and cellphone record analysis to establish a timeline connecting the suspects before, during, and after the crime.
What this signals is a shift in the strategic landscape. The barrier to entry for solving a cold case is no longer the absence of a suspect in CODIS. It is the willingness of a department to send the sample to a genealogy lab, the funding to pay for the analysis, and the legal framework to withstand a defense challenge. For families of victims like Baby Skylar, Barbara Lee, Paul Fitzmaurice, Elizabeth Acton, and Jim Johnson Jr., the technology has converted the impossible into the inevitable.
Anderson awaits sentencing on February 5, 2027.
Sources
- Woman accused in decades old ‘Baby Skylar’ case takes plea deal, pleads guilty to reduced charge
- Cold case
- Foresthill cold case breakthrough leads to arrests of victim's wife, daughter more than 4 years later
- Witnesses recount cold-case evidence as prosecutors seek trial in 2004 Fresno murder
- Woman missing since 1994 identified in decades-old cold case
- 4 men arrested in 2013 Orlando cold case kidnapping, murder
Photo: Diplomatic Security Service (Public domain)




