Karl Karlsen collected insurance money after his first wife died in a California house fire, after a barn fire killed three horses, and after his son was crushed by a pickup truck in New York. For years, authorities ruled each death an accident.
Initial Tragedies and Early Red Flags
On New Year’s Day 1991, Christina Karlsen died in a fire at the family home in Murphys, California. She was taking a bath when flames engulfed the house. Karl Karlsen told investigators he was in the garage and pulled their two daughters and son Levi to safety, but could not reach Christina through a boarded-up bathroom window. The fire was ruled an accident.
State fire investigator Carl Kent arrived at the scene and noticed a strong smell of kerosene in the hallway outside the bathroom. Burn patterns suggested the fire started there. Kent believed the origins were suspicious. He was told by supervisors there was not enough money for him to travel to New York to interview Karl Karlsen. The case was closed.
The family moved back to Seneca Falls, New York. Karl Karlsen married Cindy Best. In November 2002, a fire destroyed the family barn, killing three Belgian draft horses. Karl Karlsen collected nearly $115,000 in insurance proceeds. The fire was ruled an accident after a brief investigation, though family members harbored suspicions.
The Role of Insurance Payouts in the Scheme
By November 2008, Levi Karlsen, 23, had earned his GED and was working on an old pickup truck at the family farm in Varick, New York. Karl Karlsen had taken out a life insurance policy on Levi just 17 days earlier. When Karl and Cindy returned from a funeral, Karl said he found Levi dead, pinned beneath the truck. The death was initially considered accidental. Karl Karlsen received $707,000 on the policy.
Cindy Karlsen later told investigators that before they left for the funeral, Karl had been alone with Levi in the barn. She also learned Karl had used some of the insurance money to buy a $1.2 million life insurance policy on her life. She testified she realized she “would be worth $1.2 million dead to Karl.”
Investigative Oversights and Closed Cases
The 1991 fire investigation stalled when funding was denied for a follow-up interview. The 2002 barn fire drew a quick accidental ruling despite the substantial payout. The 2008 death of Levi Karlsen generated a $707,000 payout on a brand-new policy, yet the case went inactive for years. In each instance, the financial motive was visible in the record, but no agency connected the deaths across state lines.
How Cindy Karlsen’s Investigation Changed the Outcome
By late 2011, Cindy Karlsen’s suspicions deepened. She hired a private investigator and confided in her cousin, Jackie Hymel, in Kentucky. Hymel called the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office in February 2012. Lieutenant John Cleere took the call and began reviewing Levi’s death.
Cindy Karlsen bought a digital recorder and met Karl at restaurants, hinting at reconciliation if he told the truth. Police then equipped her with a hidden microphone for a meeting at Abigail’s Restaurant in Seneca Falls on November 16, 2012. Four plain-clothes detectives sat nearby. Karl denied intentionally causing the truck to fall but said, “I took advantage of the situation when it happened.”
Days later, investigators brought Karl Karlsen to the Seneca County Sheriff’s Department for a 9.5-hour interview. He changed his story several times. He finally admitted the truck fell on Levi after he climbed into the cab. He confessed that he left Levi trapped under the truck, alive, and did not try to help him.
The Path to Confessions and Convictions
Karl Karlsen was arrested and charged with insurance fraud and second-degree murder. On November 6, 2013, the day before his trial was to start, he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and was sentenced to 15 years to life in prison.
The conviction prompted California authorities to revisit the 1991 fire. Carl Kent provided his original case files. Investigators spoke with witnesses and re-examined evidence. They concluded Karl Karlsen had deliberately set the fire to kill Christina and collect insurance. In August 2014, he was charged in Calaveras County with first-degree murder. He was convicted in February 2020 and sentenced to life in prison.
Karl Karlsen continues to proclaim his innocence, telling Dateline he only confessed because he was tired and needed pain medication, and that the tragedies were bad luck.
Sources
- How did Karl Karlsen’s second wife help expose his son’s murder? Inside the investigation that changed the case
- Mom of 3 Died in a Mysterious Fire. 17 Years Later, Her Son's Death Exposed the Sinister Truth | Oxygen
Photo: Sandstein (CC BY 3.0)




