TALLAHASSEE, November 18, 2026 — Florida Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia announced four additional arrests Tuesday in Gadsden County connected to a $1.7 million property damage fraud scheme, bringing the total number of defendants to 37. The latest arrests include three state employees, pushing the count of state workers charged in the case to 17.
The Statutory Authority Behind the Badge
The Florida Constitution establishes the Chief Financial Officer as a statewide elected officer and places the Department of Financial Services under the CFO’s direction. The department’s portfolio spans financial services regulation, insurance oversight, the State Fire Marshal, and a law-enforcement arm: the Criminal Investigations Division. That division holds statewide authority to investigate and arrest for financial crimes, including fraud against the state, insurance fraud, and arson. Its officers carry the same arrest powers as any Florida law-enforcement agency but operate exclusively within the financial crimes lane.
How the Investigative Apparatus Works
The Criminal Investigations Division runs on a referral and intelligence model. Cases originate from whistleblower tips, audit findings, insurance company referrals, and data analytics that flag anomalous claims patterns. Once a case opens, division investigators — sworn law-enforcement officers — conduct interviews, execute search warrants, and build probable cause for arrest. The division does not prosecute; it coordinates with the relevant state attorney’s office for charging decisions and trial. In the Gadsden County scheme, the division handled the investigation from the initial February arrest of former state employee Briana McCarthy through each subsequent wave of arrests.
The $1.7 Million Case as Operational Example
Investigators allege McCarthy, while employed by the state, processed $1.7 million in fraudulent property damage claims for family members and acquaintances. The arrests have unfolded in distinct waves: five additional arrests followed McCarthy’s in February, four more later that month, six in April, seven in August, and four on November 17. The latest defendants — Damien Chapman, Nikia Pender, Devecchio Sailor, and Veronica Chapman — face charges of grand theft and cashing an item with intent to defraud. Ingoglia’s office identified Chapman, Pender, and Sailor as current state employees.
Scale and Prosecutorial Coordination
The case now encompasses 37 total arrests, with 17 of those defendants identified as state employees. Each arrest wave required coordination with the state attorney’s office in the relevant judicial circuit to align charges and ensure the investigative file supported prosecution. Ingoglia stated his office will “pursue every investigative lead to uncovering every person involved in stealing from the taxpayers,” signaling the investigation remains open.
Ingoglia’s Role Directing the Apparatus
Ingoglia has served as CFO since July 2025, appointed by Governor Ron DeSantis after Jimmy Patronis resigned to run for Congress. A former state legislator and Republican Party of Florida chairman, Ingoglia directs the department’s investigative priorities and public posture on financial crime. The Gadsden County case illustrates how the CFO uses the Criminal Investigations Division as a force multiplier: a single fraudulent processor inside a state agency spawned a network of 37 defendants across multiple counties, all pursued by a division that answers directly to the CFO.
Sources
- Blaise Ingoglia
- Blaise Ingoglia: projected victory in 2026 | CiberCuba
- CFO Ingoglia: Four more arrested in alleged $1.7 million scheme involving state employees
- Four more charged in $1.7 million property damage fraud scheme, now totalling 37 arrests
- Florida CFO claims Seminole County is overspending by $77 million
Photo: Office of the Chief Financial Officer of Florida (Public domain)




